Dewalt VS Makita Sub-compact Reciprocating saw showdown
When you need a bit more power than a hacksaw, but don’t want the heft of a full size reciprocating saw, you grab a sub compact. We put these 2 saws to the test cutting a treated 4x4 fence post with the exact same Dewalt wood with nails 6 inch blade. Lets jump right into the showdown.
For the test we used fully charged 5ah batteries in both, we ran 6 tests for both and choose the 3 fastest of those tests to average for the best times for each tool.
Dewalt DCS367 - Average time 16.37
Run 1 - 13.21
Run 2 - 14.35
Run 3 - 21.55
Makita XJRO7 - Average time 33.15
Run 1 - 30.35
Run 2 - 32.32
Run 3 - 36.80
Dewalt DCS367 Specs
Up to 2.5x more runtime*
Compact 14.5" length fits in between studs & in other tight spots
Only 5 lbs. in weight (tool only)
Keyless 4-Position Blade Clamp for quick & easy blade changes & cutting versatility
1-1/8" stroke length
Variable speed trigger delivers up to 2,900 SPM
Bright LED light to illuminate dark work areas
Zach - Dewalt Review
This is a mean compact reciprocating saw. Great for making one handed cuts. Still enough front grip for two handed cuts if added pressure is needed. Great duel angle blade chuck. A little more front heavy then the Makita. Also more vibration while cutting.
Indy - Dewalt Review
Dewalt brought the bigger guns to this showdown, definitely more power as we saw in testing, but the balance of the saw is more towards the front which is actually a good thing while cutting with 2 hands. I agree with Zach on the dual angle positions, very cool feature Dewalt.
Zachs Final Thoughts
Both Saws have their pros and cons. I found the Dewalt compact recip saw more powerful when doing a comparison cutting test. Although I found the Makita more manageable. This was because of less vibration and slightly slower cutting speed. I would recommend both saws for purchase depending on what your using them for. I would suggest the Dewalt if your looking for a saw that can do tight cuts on lumber or tree limbs. For the Makita I would recommend using it for pvc, conduit, plastic sheets, and thinner lumber. I'm also going to be reaching for the Makita if I'm doing smaller cutting work on a ladder, again because its more manageable. Definitely both very useful saws.
Dewalt vs Makita cut times
Makita XJRO7 Specs
Makita-built brushless motor delivers 0-3,000 strokes per minute combined with a 13/16" stroke length for faster and more efficient cutting
Compact and ergonomic design at only 12-1/2" long
Weighs only 5.7 lbs. with battery for reduced operator fatigue
Ideal for working in tight spaces
"Tool-less" blade change system allows for faster blade installation and removal for increased productivity
Reinforced fixed shoe for added durability
Electric brake for maximum productivity
Built-in L.E.D. light with preglow and afterglow illuminate the work area
Rubberized soft grip handle provides increased comfort on the job
Indy - Makita Review
Slightly smaller and slightly cheaper than the Dewalt, the Makita is a smooth saw, but the lack of power compared to the Dewalt is noticeable in testing. For lighter work loads, it’s a great saw.
It’s got a more balanced design than the Dewalt, with more of the weight near the back, unlike the Dewalt which is more front heavy.
Zach - Makita Review
Nice sleak design. Love the color scheme of the sub compact which is black with white lettering. Also has plastic spacers in the battery holster to keep it tighter then Dewalt battary. While cutting definitely less vibration compared to the Dewalt.
Indy’s Final Thoughts
While Dewalt clearly won this showdown, both saws still have there place in your tool box. When your working in a tight place these are the saws of choice to bring. I gotta give it to Dewalt here.
